Best Company for Printing Photos
Choosing the best company for printing photos means balancing quality, price, paper choices, and how much effort you want to put in. The right lab makes your images look faithful to the screen and holds up over time; the wrong one wastes money and leaves colors flat or skin tones wrong. This comparison focuses on the leading consumer and prosumer services in the U.S., covering what each does well, where it falls short, and who should use it.
More from this site
Keep reading the latest coverage
Several factors matter more than marketing claims. Print quality depends on the printer and ink system, the paper or media, and how the lab profiles its color output. Price shifts with paper type, print size, and whether you order single prints or large volumes. Convenience includes upload methods, proofing tools, shipping speed, and how easy it is to reorder. Longevity matters for archival work: pigment-based inks and acid-free papers resist fading far better than dye-based prints on standard paper.
| Company | Print Quality | Price Range (per 8x10) | Paper Options | Turnaround | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mpix | Excellent; deep blacks, accurate skin tones | Mid to high | Luster, gloss, matte, fine art | 1–3 business days | Wedding and portrait photographers |
| Printique (formerly AdoramaPix) | Very good; consistent color | Mid | Luster, gloss, matte | 1–3 business days | Photographers who want pro lab ease |
| Shutterfly | Good; decent for casual use | Low to mid | Standard gloss and matte | 3–7 business days | Casual prints and photo books |
| Nations Photo Lab | Excellent; lab-grade profiling | Mid to high | Luster, gloss, matte, fine art | 2–5 business days | Serious hobbyists and small studios |
| Costco Photo Center | Good for the price | Low | Gloss and matte only | 1–2 hours in-store | Budget-friendly same-day prints |
| Walgreens / CVS | Adequate; colors can be dull | Low | Standard gloss and matte | Same-day in-store | Quick, inexpensive everyday prints |
Print Quality and Color Accuracy
Mpix and Nations Photo Lab stand out for color accuracy and shadow detail. Both use professional inkjet systems and custom profiles, which means skin tones look natural and highlights recover cleanly. Printique sits close behind, offering consistent results with less hands-on tweaking. Shutterfly has improved its quality but still leans toward a slightly cooler, less dynamic look that works for casual family prints but may disappoint for fine art or portraiture. Drugstore chains like Walgreens and CVS deliver acceptable snapshots, but their dye-based prints on thin paper lack depth and are best reserved for everyday use.
Paper Choices and Finishes
The paper you choose changes how an image feels and how long it lasts. Luster and gloss prints have deeper blacks and more contrast, making them popular for portraits and landscapes. Matte finishes reduce glare and suit gallery displays and framing without glass. Fine art papers offer a textured, gallery-quality surface but cost more and require careful handling. If you plan to sell or frame prints, investing in a lab that offers luster and fine art options is worth the extra cost.
Price and Value
Price per print drops sharply as you order larger quantities, but the base cost per print varies widely. Drugstore and mass-market services are cheapest for small runs and offer frequent promotions, but their quality ceiling is lower. Mpix and Nations Photo Lab charge more, yet the difference shows in richer tonal gradation and better paper stock. For photographers who print regularly, a mid-range pro lab often delivers better value than the cheapest option because the prints last longer and require less post-processing correction.
Turnaround and Convenience
Same-day printing is a major advantage for events and last-minute needs. Costco Photo Center and drugstore chains excel here, with prints ready in under two hours. For mail-order services, Mpix and Printique typically deliver within a few business days. Shutterfly and Nations Photo Lab take slightly longer but offer robust online proofing tools that help you approve colors and cropping before the run starts. If you need prints for a specific date, check turnaround times during peak seasons, as holiday rushes can add days.
Durability and Archival Quality
For prints that must last decades, look for labs that use pigment-based inks and acid-free, lignin-free papers. Mpix and Nations Photo Lab both offer archival-grade options that resist fading and yellowing far better than standard dye prints. If you are printing wedding albums or heirloom images, spending a little more on archival materials protects the finished product. Casual prints intended for fridge doors or short-term displays do not need this level of investment, but it matters when permanence is the goal.
Who Should Use Which Service
- Choose Mpix if you prioritize print quality and need reliable skin tones for portraits or wedding work.
- Choose Printique for a professional lab experience with straightforward ordering and solid quality.
- Choose Nations Photo Lab if you want lab-grade results with fine art paper options and are comfortable ordering online.
- Choose Shutterfly for casual family prints and photo books where convenience outweighs the need for perfect color.
- Choose Costco or drugstore chains for budget-friendly, same-day prints when quality is secondary.
The best company for printing photos is the one that matches how you shoot, how you print, and what you are willing to pay. Testing a small batch with your preferred lab before committing to a large order is the most reliable way to find your match.