Finding the Best Fixed Annuity Rates in 2018
The search for the best fixed annuity rates in 2018 centers on a straightforward trade-off between safety and yield. After years of near-zero interest rates, the Federal Reserve raised the federal funds rate multiple times during 2018, which pushed yields on fixed annuities higher. This environment made fixed annuities a compelling option for retirees and pre-retirees seeking guaranteed income streams. The most competitive rates came from highly rated insurers offering multi-year guarantee annuities (MYGAs), which lock in an interest rate for a set period, typically ranging from two to ten years. The rate you secure today determines the growth of your contract until the end of that term, making the choice of carrier and duration critical to your overall return.
More from this site
Keep reading the latest coverage
To identify the best fixed annuity rates in 2018, we looked at direct annuities and rate tables from major insurance carriers, focusing on standard, non-commissionable products and multi-year guarantee annuities. Rates vary significantly based on the annuity type, the length of the guarantee period, and the issuing company's financial strength. Below is a comparison of the top fixed annuity rate categories available during that year.
| Annuity Type | Typical Rate Range (2018) | Guarantee Period | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Multi-Year Guarantee Annuity (MYGA) | 3.00% – 4.00% | 2 to 10 years | Safe, predictable growth over a set period |
| Fixed Indexed Annuity (FIA) | 1.50% – 3.50% | 1 to 6 years | Growth potential with a floor against market loss |
| Standard Fixed Annuity | 2.50% – 3.50% | 1 year or shorter | Short-term parking of funds with liquidity |
The MYGA remained the workhorse for those prioritizing the highest contractual rate in 2018. A ten-year MYGA from a top-rated carrier could offer a rate nearly double what a one-year fixed annuity paid, reflecting the compensation for committing your capital for a longer duration. The trade-off is clear: you sacrifice liquidity for yield. If you need the money before the guarantee period ends, surrender charges can eat into your principal, and you will miss out on the compounding benefit of the locked rate.
Top Carriers and the Rate Landscape
The best fixed annuity rates in 2018 were not evenly distributed across all insurers. Mid-size and specialty carriers often offered the most aggressive MYGA rates because they needed to attract capital to fund their growth. These companies typically had strong AM Best ratings of A or higher, which is the threshold for financial stability. The largest life insurers, by contrast, often matched or slightly trailed these top rates but offered the advantage of brand recognition and decades of claims-paying history. When comparing the best fixed annuity rates in 2018, the rating of the carrier matters as much as the number on the rate sheet, because the guarantee is only as good as the company backing it.
For fixed indexed annuities, the rate landscape in 2018 was shaped by the S&P 500's strong performance. FIAs credit interest based on the positive annual change in a selected index, subject to a cap, spread, or participation rate. The best fixed annuity rates in the FIA category came with caps around 10% to 12%, a spread of 2% to 3%, or a participation rate of 80% to 100%. A FIA with a 0% floor meant your contract value could not decline due to a negative index year, but it also meant that in a flat or down market, you would earn little to nothing. The trade-off is between the upside potential of the market and the protection against its downside.
Evaluating Surrender Charges and Liquidity
A critical component of evaluating the best fixed annuity rates in 2018 is understanding the surrender charge schedule. Most MYGAs and FIAs impose a declining penalty for early withdrawal, commonly starting at 7% to 9% in the first year and decreasing by one percentage point annually until it reaches zero. A seven-year MYGA, for example, might carry a surrender charge that disappears entirely by year eight. These charges protect the insurer's ability to hold your premium and invest it for the long term, which is how they can offer a higher rate than a bank certificate of deposit with similar duration.
Many contracts also include a free withdrawal provision, usually allowing you to withdraw up to 10% of the contract value annually without incurring a surrender charge. This provision is not the same as liquidity; it is a safety valve for unexpected needs. If you require full access to your capital, a shorter guarantee period or a standard fixed annuity with annual rate resets may be more appropriate, even if the rate is lower.
Fixed Annuity Rates vs. Alternative Safe Havens
To contextualize the best fixed annuity rates in 2018, compare them to other conservative vehicles. The average yield on a five-year certificate of deposit at a national bank hovered around 2.50% to 3.00% during the year, while the yield on a ten-year Treasury note reached roughly 2.90% at the end of 2018. The top MYGA rates from specialty carriers exceeded these benchmarks by a meaningful margin, especially at the five- and ten-year durations. The difference is that the annuity rate is guaranteed for the contract term, while a bank rate can be adjusted at renewal and a Treasury yield fluctuates daily in the secondary market before maturity.
The tax treatment of a fixed annuity also differentiates it from a taxable brokerage account. Interest inside an annuity compounds tax-deferred until you withdraw it, which means you do not pay taxes on the growth each year. For investors in high tax brackets, this deferral can compound into a significant advantage over a taxable equivalent investment like a municipal bond or a certificate of deposit. However, withdrawals from a non-qualified annuity are taxed as ordinary income, not the lower capital gains rate, which can be a disadvantage for high earners in the withdrawal phase.
Picking the Right Annuity for Your Situation
The best fixed annuity rates in 2018 depended on your timeline, tax situation, and liquidity needs. A retiree with a lump sum who will not need the money for a decade and wants a guaranteed, predictable return likely found the best value in a ten-year MYGA from a top-rated carrier. The rate lock eliminated reinvestment risk and provided a clear picture of the contract's end value. An investor closer to retirement who wanted some market exposure without the risk of loss might have favored a fixed indexed annuity with a strong crediting strategy and a moderate surrender period.
For those who already had a pension or Social Security covering essential expenses, a fixed annuity served as a risk-managed growth layer rather than an income source. The principal protection and guaranteed rate allowed the rest of the portfolio to take on more risk elsewhere. Understanding these roles is essential because the best fixed annuity rate for one investor can be the wrong product for another, depending on how the contract fits into the broader financial plan.